Forgiving Flaws on Mother’s Day

2012-05-09 03.34.47

Mother’s Day. I’m not a fan of these Hallmark Holidays. (well, I admit to liking Valentine’s Day.) I agree with  this piece by Annie Lamott. Becoming a mother was the best thing I ever did – but as Annie says, it’s not for everyone and not everyone is good at it. And those of us with either dead mothers or fraught relationships must grapple with our grief and complex emotions amidst this jolly day of bon-bons and brunches.

The distance I felt with my mother was made more comfortable by actual distance – so for much of my adult life I lived either across or out of the country – far from her. It was only after I moved back to the United States with my 1 year old daughter that I felt a shift, the possibility for real connection. A year later, she died.

I believe my mother did the best she could.  She once told a friend that were she do do it all over again she would not have had kids. For a time, I thought that a terrible thing to say but I realize now this was not because she didn’t love her kids.  Rather, she thought she would have preferred pursuing other things that, having 4 children with barely a year between them and teaching high school, precluded. She was smart as a whip and passionate about social injustice and would have been a great lefty- lawyer or maybe a politician. Who knows. She was launched almost obliviously into motherhood the way many Irish Catholic women in the fifties were.  It was all she could do to keep herself and the rest of us afloat. So we floated.

Desmond Tutu and his daughter Mpho Tutu have written a book about Forgiveness and are promoting it with a lovely online, month long “Forgiveness Challenge”. I signed up because I love Bishop Tutu and because I want to stay forgiveness-fit. I believe and history has shown us, that this is the only way to thrive after injury. Each day there are short readings, sometimes with a video or audio, a poem or interviews on forgiveness. One of the first forgiveness-excercises in the Challenge is to decided who you want to forgive.  My mother is on my list just as I suspect I would be on my daughter’s. We are not perfect, us mothers.

Today, I forgive my mother for never telling me how incredible being a mother can be. Did she not think so? For me, every stage of nurturing and loving my kid through life has been precious. From the moment I saw my daughter, then held her, I was a goner.  I’d been in love before, but nothing compared to the space this infant created in my heart.

Home from the Hospital  Six Weeks Later - July 1995

I watch my daughter as she ventures into adulthood and remember my own first steps – really more of a leap to claim (save?) my life. My daughter is now concocting dreams, considering the possibilities for her future. I remember myself in my 20s as completely narcissistic, thinking only about what I wanted to do next, what would bring me satisfaction, or better, joy. What a luxury! My mother was too busy juggling diapers and bottles. On the other hand, as I neared 30, I started to get a little sick of myself – this perpetual focus on my needs, my desires. I began to get an inkling of the appeal of being needed. A brush with mortality clinched my determination to be a mother and to this day, I consider it a revelation. It is where I found joy.

My mother did not come to motherhood out of longing as I did. I think even becoming a grandmother surprised her. But I bet she would have been good at it – and had we the chance, we would have shared our joy and perhaps, discovered each other.

This entry was posted in Grief and Healing and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Forgiving Flaws on Mother’s Day

  1. Avatar dianeprokop says:

    Lovely piece! I think my mom and yours were cut from the same cloth. I have forgiven her. She did the best that she could. And your mom made you the great mom you are, somehow. Happy Mother’s Day to you!

  2. Avatar Tricia says:

    Your comments (and the fact that you’re reading) always makes me smile. Thanks, Diane!

  3. Hey, thanks for following! I rarely return the favor, though I know it’s standard etiquette, however, I have just read a handful and really enjoy your posts. Especially this one. I, too, am done with the saccharine sentimentality of commercialized holidays. It is doubly difficult to be forcibly expected to feel an emotion or a sense of gratitude that does not come naturally. Though I am fortunate to enjoy healthy relationships with both my mom and my daughter, I know too many people who – for whatever reason – don’t. It is good to be able to question and examine the tenets of all of our bonds without having to feel guilty that somehow we’re less human for doing so. Write on 🙂

  4. Avatar Lea Sylvestro says:

    Such a thoughtful, loving, and forgiving piece. And I LOVE the photo of you and that precious bundle! And you’re so right….you think you know what love feels like and then you have that baby….new world! XXOO

  5. Avatar cynthia says:

    Lovely piece full of truths. And such fun to see the photo of you and your daughter.

Leave a Reply